Comments on: Web Sites: Designed by Dogs, Managed by Cats

By: Brian Carter

Brian Carter — Thu, 12 Jul 2007 17:06:57 +0000

Ya, I’d agree- the post is not bad, but the cat part of the analogy is underdeveloped, so all we get is the sense that the dog is excessive but it leaves us hanging wanting to know how to balance cat and dog- makes me wonder if the author is thinking of a specific person they view as a dog who has made managing the website difficult for him.

By: Anne Rogers

Anne Rogers — Thu, 12 Jul 2007 15:22:04 +0000

Actually, I disagree with a fair amount of this.
In my experience, I’ve found that it’s those who design the websites who most manage to remain focussed on the functionality and content (not swamping users with a world of information).. and the cat clients are the ones who are fascinated by technology, choosing colours and fonts and adding all the content they could ever dream of – they just don’t consider how to handle the maintenance that comes with it!

By: Anne Rogers

Anne Rogers — Thu, 12 Jul 2007 15:17:33 +0000

By: John Blackmore

John Blackmore — Tue, 10 Jul 2007 21:03:56 +0000

I’m a dog person, but to be honest, I approach the Web in a more reptilian manner. Cold-blooded. To be kinder to myself, it’s more like being a mathematician.
The question is not what can we put up, nor how can we navigate it–the question is what do you want it to do? What do the users want it to do? There’s a VENN diagram where our two wants intersect, and that’s your Website. That’s not being the dog-like “putter-upper” as Gerry’s said before–or whatever the cats are.
Your freedom from dogland is in your metrics–and your metrics have to tie to a strategy–and your strategy better back what the business says it wants to do.

By: Angela Kirwin

Angela Kirwin — Fri, 06 Jul 2007 00:25:44 +0000

Well said! I like the analogy too. It explains some of my own conflicted as both a web designer (dog) and client of a web designer (cat).
Now, if a cat designed a web site. What would it look like and how would it work?
A
A

By: Cam Beck

Cam Beck — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 16:16:57 +0000

[lightbulb]
Thank you, Gerry!

By: Gerry McGovern

Gerry McGovern — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 16:01:46 +0000

On my travels I come across all these huge, rambling, neglected websites. They all started off with great ambition and enthusiasm. They grew and grew and grew as more and more content and stuff got added. And now they are out of control. And nobody is really responsible, or wants responsibility.
Once I said to someone who was supposed to be responsible for their website, that they should read over every page at least once a year. “If I had to do that,” they exclaimed, “it would take me a year!” And …
I love my dog’s enthusiasm. And people are often very enthusiastic about publishing new stuff on their sites. But are soon as you ask them to do basic things like regularly review–right before your eyes–they turn from dogs to cats.

By: Anna Bella

Anna Bella — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 15:54:52 +0000

What a neat analogy! And, it actually answers my question of “why I’m my own worst customer” when it comes to my own PR…I’m playing the role of both the dog and the cat…we’re always fighting

By: Cam Beck

Cam Beck — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 15:39:35 +0000

Nicely done. As you said, we need a touch of a dog’s enthusiasm to please others to go along with their fierce loyalty. I’m still trying to figure out how cats play into all of this, though. Why would we turn over the management of the website to the cat, who only cares for its own needs?
I can see it now:
“Whatever, dude. You handle this. I’m going to lie in the sunlight. Next time you bother me, make sure it’s important.”
Cats DO have a great ability to hunt. Perhaps if we could use anything a cat could bring, it would be that. Imagine being able to find and sneak up to the right target like a cat finds its prey… and then when we do, we act like a dog and do our best to serve and protect.
?

By: Lewis Green

Lewis Green — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 14:31:52 +0000

Gerry,
This is some of the best writing I have read here. Great analogies, and I get it. As Paul says, “there’s some good nuggets in this post…”
I think most of us are part dog and part cat. My web site is chuck full of content and links. Now I have to remember to delete old stuff and add new stuff. I can manage but I sometimes wonder if my homepage is a bit too busy, but the dog in me won’t let me delete anything. My eyes are pinned on the page and my tail wags incessantly.

By: Paul Barsch

Paul Barsch — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 14:11:42 +0000

Dogs and cats aside, there’s some good nuggets in this post…

By: John Whiteside

John Whiteside — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 13:53:59 +0000

OMG, dogs and cats, this is like Mac vs Windows.
Speaking as a dog & cat person, well, the cat is a bundle of love who welcomes me home when I’ve been gone for an hour, wants to cuddle a lot, and generally is the perfect buddy. And he likes having an 80 pound lab lick his head. So everybody’s happy.
Cats are usually standoffish if they’re not socialized properly from kittenhood… like a lot of dogs who aren’t socialized properly when they’re pups. For either species, they’re instincts are to stick to their own kind, and if they don’t get a lot of people attention when they’re little, instincts rule for cats AND dogs.
It’s all in how you bring ‘em up.
Is this a marketing blog?

By: Spike

Spike — Thu, 05 Jul 2007 13:46:02 +0000

That was….weird.
Sounds like you’re a cat guy (in the animal sense, not the web design sense). I’m a dog guy (again, in pet ownership sense) – just ask the neighborhood cat that uses the top of my convertible as his own personal bed/claw sharpening device each night. In my experience, cats are generally uninterested and uncaring. They know you’re going to feed them. They know they can treat you poorly. They’re too smart for their own good.
Dogs are loyal. Happy to see you. Will bend over backwards for you. And they are affectionate.
Each have their faults. But I’ll take dogs any day of the week – and definitely not for the web design reasons in your post.