MarketingProfs

Member Login | About Us | Members Benefits | PRO Members

MarketingProfs Daily Fix Blog

Gavin Heaton
Gavin Heaton   BIO
10.20.08

Not All Conversations Are Equal

We used to say that “the only thing worse than being talked about is NOT being talked about.” But things have changed. You see, when the advertising challenge was to “cut through.” repetition was its own virtue; while in this Age of Conversation, the factors which determine marketing success are more closely related to the intangible factors of trust, reputation and social currency.

The Ruby Pseudo team have a great post on the Teen Commandments for Brands Wanting to Go Digital
…. but the same lessons can easily be applied to any audience and any
form of engagement that is based on two-way (or polyphonic)
communication. Commandment Ten states:

10. Finally, with Facebook and MySpace etc, please remember that
you’re in their (digital) space: they didn’t ask you to be there, and
they can’t very well ask you to leave, so talk nicely. And if you
haven’t got anything nice to say, don’t say anything at all…

Just because intangible factors are harder to measure does not mean
they are less relevant when it comes to your brand. It just means that
you have to use insight not as IDEATION but as execution – and that
means a whole lot more listening and much less shouting. Or as Mark Hancock said, “It is not the aspiration that is at fault – it is the implementation”.
markhancockideas
This is more important than ever. In What’s Greater than Sex?, Scott Monty shares the results of a recent survey
into the media habits of American men in the 18-35 age group. One of
the key findings is that the Internet is considered more important (as
in “can’t live without) than TV. But look also at the context in which
these men live their lives:

  • 63% have a smart phone and one in four use their mobile device to connect to the Web
  • 40% use the Internet for more than 22 hours a week    
  • 36% say they can’t live without the Internet for socializing
  • 33% say they can’t live without online entertainment    
  • 59% notice online ads
  • 35% like ads that allow them to play a game    
  • 34% like online ads that allow them to participate in a contest

Obviously there is a seismic shift underway

Why is this important? Because the printing press … and for that
matter, blogs, social networks, video and picture sharing tools,
conversational and other “Web 2.0″ sites are not just tools. They don’t
just FACILITATE communication and interaction. They MEDIATE it. The
impact of this is profound. 

If the way that we understand the world is, in turn, mediated by it,
then those brands that do NOT engage with new media are placed at a
significant disadvantage. This goes beyond the question of whether your
company or brand “should have a website” or a “blog”, but whether it is
important for you to be part of the web of signification that creates
the worlds that we live in.

This is serious news for
ANY brand whose normal go-to-market approach relies on traditional,
broadcast-style campaigning – but in TOUGH economic times, the impact
of this will be felt more keenly. If you are not actively creating the
conditions in which your brand will thrive, and if you are not adding
value to the conversations that circulate around your brand, then
irrelevance will be the death of your business.

Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Sphinn
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Add to favorites
  • Posterous
  • FriendFeed
  • Google Bookmarks

5 Responses to “Not All Conversations Are Equal”

  1. Elaine Fogel says:

    Hey, Gavin. I totally agree with your point that, “the factors which determine marketing success are more closely related to the intangible factors of trust, reputation and social currency.”
    Just one thing concerns me that has more to do with psychology than marketing. Has technology given 18-35 year-old males a protective shield behind which they can hide? Does being addicted to social technology mean less skills and ability to socialize in person and make “real” relationships?
    Based on anecdotal stories I hear from my 24-year-old daughter and her friends, it appears that many young men today are “delayed” in their social skills and ability to be “real.”

  2. I just LOVE your graphic about Web 2.0 and how a company should be interacting. I have been trying to do exactly what the graphic demonstrates with the Queensboro blog at http://queensboro.wordpress.com
    I have not found a good way to explain the blog and “social media” goals.
    I completely agree that the products and the conversation both have to be beneficial for the customers, and that hand in hand, they help build the brand.
    Though I am a writer, I have found it difficult to explain with words what the graphic does so beautifully! Thank you for the useful post. I have shared it with my team.

  3. Gavin Heaton says:

    Interesting question, Elaine. I have recently come to know a number of young 20-something men who are actively involved in social media and it is the opposite. Their online relationships seamlessly merge with the real world relationships … and in fact, they see no discontinuity.

  4. Gavin Heaton says:

    Kate … to be honest, it’s not my graphic. It is Mark’s. And it is excellent, I agree.

  5. Well, good job to Mark! It is an excellent graphic.

Leave a Reply