MarketingVOX: The sudden departure of marketing executive Julie Roehm, followed by the firing of DraftFCB, the agency that Roehm tapped for Wal-Mart’s creative duties, has raised concerns among industry watchers of a possible ethical breach by the Chicago-based agency.
Many industry insiders say that to restore its reputation and minimize long-term damage DraftFCB needs to quickly respond to its abrupt firing by Wal-Mart, the Chicago Tribune writes. They say the agency should immediately investigate its actions in regard to the Wal-Mart account, and either publicly contest the firing or dismiss anyone who acted unethically.
Wal-Mart said it fired Draft FCB because of “new information we have obtained over the past few weeks,” but did not divulge other information. “We are not going to disclose any details,” said Wal-Mart spokeswoman Mona Williams.
Industry watchers say Roehm’s departure was likely due to violations of Wal-Mart’s ethics policies, which prohibit employees from accepting anything of value from vendors. In September, Roehm was invited by DraftFCB to attend an AdForum dinner at Nobu, an expensive Japanese restaurant in New York City. Retailers usually are not invited to attend such presentations. After DraftFCB’s presentation, Roehm praised DraftFCB’s integration of direct-mail and advertising expertise as a new model for the industry.
“We’re still disappointed, but we’re focused on the future. We have a very good, strong reputation for delivering results for clients and for being a good partner,” Wally Petersen, DraftFCB spokesman, is quoted as saying.
Related stories:
- Wal-Mart Account Back in Play after Roehm Ouster
- Roehm, Womack Out at Wal-Mart
- Wal-Mart Offers Movie Download/DVD Bundle
- WOMMA Review Unlikely to Hurt Edelman
- Wal-Mart’s Nightmare: Site Down on Black Friday
- Advertisers Eager for e-Media Exchange, Cable Cautious
- Ethical WOM: Blogs Influence, Flogs Fool
- Wal-Mart Subscribes to ‘Project Apollo’ Pilot Panel
- Wal-Mart Taps Draft FCB, Carat for $580MM Account
- More Fake Wal-Mart Blogs, Edelman Fesses up
- After the Walmarting Comes the Edelmaning
- Wal-Mart Toy Microsite Draws Consumer Fire
- The Walmarting of the Blogosphere
- Wal-Mart Shuts Down MySpace Clone
- Wal-Mart Brief Focuses on Cross-Selling
- Wal-Mart Taps Saatchi X, Agency Search Continues
- Task Force to Unveil Electronic Ad Trading Details
- Jeff Bell Leaves Chrysler for Microsoft
- Wal-Mart Leads Call for Online Marketplace for TV Ads
- Wal-Mart Recruits Bloggers for PR Battle
- Wal-Mart Expands Marketing Department
- Wal-Mart Launches Multimedia Ad Campaign
- Walmart.com Shuts Down Recommendation Feature
- Wal-Mart Names Fleming CMO
- Wal-Mart Addresses PR Storm with Site, Search Campaign
